Fistula symptoms are easy to mistake for piles. Both can cause pain, itching and a little blood near the anus, so many people assume a sore spot or lump is haemorrhoids and wait for it to settle. An anal fistula behaves differently: it is a small tunnel that keeps leaking or flaring up, and it rarely closes without treatment. Discharge of pus or smelly fluid that keeps returning, a small opening in the skin beside the anus, and pain that eases and flares in the same spot all point towards a fistula. Our colorectal surgery service at Bilba Clinic assesses both conditions, so you do not have to work out which one you have on your own.
What Is Fistula Disease?
An anal fistula is a small tunnel that links the end of the bowel to the skin around the anus. “Fistula disease” is simply another way of describing this condition. The word disease can sound alarming, but a fistula is not contagious and it can be treated.
The tunnel usually starts when a gland just inside the anus becomes infected and forms an abscess. Once the pus drains, a channel can remain. It keeps leaking fluid because the bowel keeps feeding it, which is why a fistula rarely heals on its own and surgery is usually needed to close it.
Fistulas are often described as simple or complex. A simple fistula is low and short. A complex one runs higher and passes through more of the muscle that controls the bowel. The type shapes the treatment.
Most fistulas have an inner opening inside the anal canal and an outer opening on the skin. The inner opening is where the infection started, and the outer opening is where fluid escapes. Some fistulas have more than one outer opening, and some have branches, which is part of why a careful examination matters. A tunnel that looks tiny on the skin can be longer and deeper than it appears. That is also why symptoms can seem to disappear and reappear.
Where Fistula Symptoms and Causes Come From
Knowing where a fistula comes from helps explain its symptoms, because most of them trace back to the same infected channel.
Why an Abscess Usually Comes First
About 3 in 4 fistulas develop after an anal abscess. The abscess is a painful, swollen collection of pus beside the anus, often with redness, warmth and sometimes a high temperature. When it bursts or is drained, the channel left behind can become a fistula. Abscesses elsewhere on the body are drained in a similar way, as our guide to skin abscess treatment explains.
Less Common Causes Worth Knowing
Not every fistula follows an abscess. Crohn’s disease, diverticulitis, hidradenitis suppurativa, tuberculosis, HIV and complications of surgery can all cause one. A fistula that keeps returning, or that appears alongside long-standing bowel symptoms, is a reason to look for an underlying cause. A similar tunnel-forming problem at the top of the buttock crease is a pilonidal sinus, which is a different condition with a different treatment.
Symptoms of Anal Fistula Most People Notice
The symptoms of anal fistula tend to build and repeat rather than arrive all at once. The most common are:
- Constant or throbbing pain near the anus, often worse when sitting, moving, coughing or opening your bowels
- Smelly discharge or pus that stains underwear or toilet paper
- Skin irritation, redness or soreness around the opening
- Swelling near the anus, sometimes with a high temperature when an abscess is forming
Some people also notice blood or pus when they pass stools, and a few notice leakage from the bowel. Symptoms often ease for a while when the fistula drains and then return. That repeating pattern is what most clearly separates a fistula from piles. A flare with swelling and fever usually means an abscess has formed in or beside the tunnel, while a quieter, weeping phase usually means the tunnel is draining. Both belong to the same condition. The three sections below cover the early picture, bowel-related changes and what can be seen on the skin.
Fistula Early Symptoms Often Start as an Abscess
A tender, hot swelling near the anus, rising pain and sometimes a fever usually come first, and these are the fistula early symptoms most people notice. They tend to build over a few days. Relief often follows when the abscess bursts and fluid or pus escapes. After that, a discharge that persists or a spot that keeps weeping is the usual sign that a channel has formed. There is no precise point at which an early fistula becomes an established one, so any recurring discharge near the anus deserves an examination, even if the pain has gone.
Fistula Bowel Symptoms When You Go to the Toilet
Opening your bowels is often when fistula bowel symptoms become easier to spot. Pain can sharpen during and after a stool, and pus or blood may appear on the paper or in the toilet. In some people the muscle around the anus is affected and bowel control is weaker, which can cause leakage. These are problems of the anal canal itself. Digestive symptoms such as bloating or a change in bowel habit point elsewhere in the bowel and need their own assessment.
Signs of Anal Fistula You Can See Around the Skin
A mirror can sometimes reveal the signs of anal fistula. Look for a small opening or pinhead-sized spot in the skin near the anus, which may look like a boil or a pimple that never heals. It may leak clear fluid, pus or blood, and the skin around it can be red, hard or tender. Do not squeeze or probe it, as this can push infection deeper.
Anal Fistula or Piles? How to Tell Them Apart
Piles usually cause bright red blood after a stool, itching and a soft lump, and they often settle within days. A fistula usually causes recurring discharge, throbbing pain and a small opening in the skin, and it keeps coming back. If symptoms return in the same place, a fistula is more likely than piles.
Piles are swollen cushions of tissue inside or around the anus. They can also cause mucus and discomfort. Our guide to haemorrhoid treatment covers what can be done when they do not settle. A fistula is a tunnel, so the picture is different:
- Piles: bright red blood on the paper or in the bowl, often with little pain, and a soft lump that may come and go
- Fistula: pus or smelly discharge, throbbing pain, a small opening in the skin and symptoms that return after easing
- Both: itching, soreness and some blood, which is why the two get confused
Where the symptoms overlap, guessing is unreliable, and it is possible to have piles and a fistula together. New or persistent bleeding needs its own look, and our guide to rectal bleeding explains the patterns that matter. An examination, usually with a short proctoscopy, can tell the two apart.
Other Conditions That Can Look Similar
Piles are not the only look-alike. An anal fissure, which is a small tear in the lining of the anal canal, tends to cause sharp pain when you pass a stool. Skin tags are soft flaps of skin that can itch or catch when you clean. A boil-like lump near the anus may be an abscess, and a lump higher up the buttock crease may be a pilonidal sinus. A fistula can sit behind any of these labels, most often when a “boil” keeps coming back in the same place. Because the treatments differ, an accurate diagnosis saves time and avoids treating the wrong problem.
What Happens If You Have a Fistula and Leave It?
If you leave a fistula untreated, the usual outcome is not a sudden emergency, but it is not a stable situation either. Symptoms may ease when the tunnel drains and then return, and each flare can bring a new abscess. Repeated infection can create extra tunnels or make the fistula more complex, which can make later treatment harder. Ongoing discharge and skin irritation also wear on comfort and daily life, which is a good reason to deal with the problem rather than manage it.
Some symptoms need prompt care: a high temperature with a swollen, hot and very painful area, redness that spreads, or pain that is quickly getting worse. These suggest a developing abscess, and urgent medical attention is the safest option. The NHS anal fistula guidance describes the same warning signs and notes that surgery is usually needed.
What Fistula Disease Treatment Involves at Bilba Clinic
Fistula disease treatment starts with a proper assessment. At Bilba Clinic, a colorectal consultation includes a clinical examination and, where needed, a proctoscopy to find the opening and judge the path of the tunnel. If it looks deep or complex, imaging such as an MRI scan may be arranged to map it before surgery.
Medication alone does not close a fistula. Surgery is usually needed, and our consultants carry out fistula surgery at the clinic. The right approach depends on where the tunnel runs in relation to the muscle that controls the bowel. For a low, simple fistula, surgery can involve opening the tunnel so it heals from the base up. Deeper tunnels are often treated with techniques that protect the muscle, such as placing a soft thread to keep the tunnel draining or covering the inner opening with a flap of nearby tissue. Which of these suits you is decided after examination and any scans, not before.
At the consultation itself, we ask when the symptoms began and whether you have had an abscess before. The examination is private. It looks for the outer opening, checks the surrounding skin and feels for any firmness along the path of the tunnel. Depending on what we find, the next step may be a proctoscopy, a scan or a plan for surgery, and we explain each option, including the risks, before you decide.
The aim is to close the tunnel while keeping as much of that muscle working as possible, because the main risks of surgery are infection, the fistula coming back and some effect on bowel control. Your surgeon will explain these for your own case before anything is agreed, along with what recovery and follow-up involve. Bring a list of your symptoms, any previous abscesses or bowel conditions, and the medicines you take, so the assessment is as complete as possible.
A colorectal consultation at Bilba Clinic starts from £250, as set out in our pricing guide. The cost of surgery depends on the procedure and is confirmed after your assessment, so you know it before you decide.

Book a Fistula Assessment at Bilba Clinic
Bilba Clinic is a CQC-registered private clinic in Fitzrovia, London. Our about page explains who we are, and we are recognised by major insurers including Bupa, Vitality, WPA and AXA.
If you have a lump, discharge or pain near the anus that keeps returning, an examination is the quickest way to know what it is. Consultations are private, and same-day appointments are often available. You can book a consultation online, and no referral is needed.
- Call: +44 (0) 7858 848 244
- Email: info@bilbaclinic.co.uk
- Visit: 57 Great Titchfield Street, Fitzrovia, London W1W 7PN, or see our contact page
- Hours: Monday to Friday 10:00 to 18:00, Saturday 12:00 to 17:00, Sunday closed
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are Fistula Symptoms?
Fistula symptoms are pain near the anus, often throbbing and worse when sitting or opening your bowels, along with smelly discharge or pus, skin irritation and swelling. Some people notice blood when they pass stools. Symptoms may ease when the fistula drains and then return, so a pattern of flaring and settling is typical.
When Should I Worry About Fistula Symptoms?
Seek prompt care if you have a high temperature with a swollen, hot, very painful area near the anus, redness that spreads, or pain that is getting worse quickly. These can mean an abscess is forming. Ongoing or returning discharge also deserves an examination, even when it is not painful.
Can You Feel a Fistula?
Sometimes. You may feel a tender lump or a hardened area near the anus, or notice a small opening in the skin that leaks. Deeper fistulas may not be felt from the outside, so a normal feel at home does not rule one out. An examination finds the tunnel and its inner opening, which cannot be seen from outside.
Can Fistula Be Painless?
It can feel painless at times, but pain is the more typical complaint. Once a fistula is draining, the pressure that built up during an abscess eases, so pain may fade while discharge and skin irritation continue. A pain-free spell does not mean it has healed, and ongoing discharge should be examined.
Why Do Fistulas Come Back?
A fistula usually returns because the tunnel or its inner opening was not fully closed, or because an abscess drained without the channel behind it being treated. Complex tunnels and underlying bowel conditions such as Crohn’s disease can make a return more likely. A thorough assessment and the right surgical approach aim to reduce it.
If symptoms return after treatment, tell your surgeon early, because a repeat assessment can find a missed branch or a cause that was not obvious the first time.
